Projects/MoveToGit/Layout

Definitions

modules:

• each SC module is one repository except kdepim, it will be split into kdepim and kdepim-runtime.
• each extragear application is one repository.
• kdereview and playground are implemented with individual repos and/or branches?
• tarballs stay the same as it is now

split:

• each SC application is one repository.
• kdelibs, and kdepimlibs are one repo each kdepim will be split into kdepim and kdepim-runtime. kdebase can be split on workspace/runtime/apps, where optionally apps could be split further
• extragear and review/playground as above.
• tarballs stay the same as it is now

Comparison

Pros for each option (cons are rephrased as a pro for the other one) Note: no mention of the magnitude of each point has been made yet.

svn2git

modules:

• some work has already been done on creating module repos
• moves within modules can be ignored

split:

• existing rules can be used with minor changes for "self contained" applications

Reviewboard

modules:

• less projects to choose from when submitting a patch? [web only, not an issue with post-review]
• no namespacing issue

split:

• if something moves to another module, no changes are needed
• ability to autocreate (and possibly assign) a review group per app, instead of per module

comments:

• the reviewer groups won't be affected

Redmine

modules:

• no namespacing issue

split:

• source code links are automatically available on each applicaton page, instead of the module page

gitolite

modules:

• no namespacing issue

split:

• easier to find projects

git

modules:

• projects can keep their interdependencies, module-wide libraries and so on
• less server space

split:

• moving a project (eg. to unmaintained) moves its whole history

user workflow

modules:

• keeps a sense of community by having a whole module kept together
• increases passive testing of trunk (more people to notice if the build's broken)
• lower barrier to hacking on other projects in the module
• easier to refactor a module [rare]
• less downloading & disk space for those who want entire modules

split:

• less downloading & disk space for people who only want a small part of a module
• easier to get started on one little app?
• easier to avoid being exposed to unstable versions of other projects [I think that's a bit selfish though]

comments:

• kdesrc-build, build-tool and mr make it easy to handle large numbers of repos, although there's still room for improvement on userfriendliness.

releases

modules:

• closer to what we have with svn??

split: