Difference between revisions of "Projects/KDE Relicensing"

Jump to: navigation, search
(Current Reply List: Add name to relicensing)
(Add myself.)
(33 intermediate revisions by 27 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
== KDE GPL v2.0 Relicensing effort ==
 
== KDE GPL v2.0 Relicensing effort ==
  
=== Why does it matter ? ===
+
=== Why does it matter? ===
  
A couple of KDE dependent projects or even libraries have moved or are going to move to GPLv3 ([http://gpl3.palamida.com:8080/ State of GPLv3 movement]).  
+
A couple of KDE dependent projects or even libraries have moved or are going to move to GPLv3.  
  
 
Unfortunately, GPL v3 is incompatible with GPL v2. This means that it is not possible to create a project linking GPL v2 and v3 code together. There is no problem for projects which are licensed GPLv2+ (version 2 or above).
 
Unfortunately, GPL v3 is incompatible with GPL v2. This means that it is not possible to create a project linking GPL v2 and v3 code together. There is no problem for projects which are licensed GPLv2+ (version 2 or above).
Line 11: Line 11:
 
Therefore, in an effort we're trying to identify the contributors that have contributed under the terms of GPLv2 and where the "+" part was not explicitly mentioned. If we know that all contributors agreed to a relicense, we can go ahead and flip the license of the individual source file.
 
Therefore, in an effort we're trying to identify the contributors that have contributed under the terms of GPLv2 and where the "+" part was not explicitly mentioned. If we know that all contributors agreed to a relicense, we can go ahead and flip the license of the individual source file.
  
== How can I help ? ==
+
== How can I help? ==
  
By identifying a contributor who as contributed under the terms of GPLv2 (use '''kdesdk/scripts/relicensecheck.pl''' on the file in question or the [http://toma.kovoks.nl/kde/ Relicense Status Page]), and contacting him if he wasn't already contacted. Ask him the following questions:  
+
By identifying a contributor who as contributed under the terms of GPLv2 (use '''kdesdk/scripts/relicensecheck.pl''' on the file in question), and contacting him if he wasn't already contacted. Ask him the following questions:  
  
* Are you okay with relicensing your contributions done under GPLv2 to GPLv2+?
+
* Are you okay with relicensing your contributions done under "GPLv2" to "GPLv2 or later"?
  
* Are you okay with relicensing your contributions done under GPLv2 to GPLv2 or GPLv3 ?
+
* Are you okay with relicensing your contributions done under "GPLv2" to "GPLv2 or GPLv3" ?
  
* Are you okay with relicensing your contributions done under LGPLv2 to LGPLv2+?
+
* Are you okay with relicensing your contributions done under "LGPLv2" to "LGPLv2 or later"?
  
* Are you okay with relicensing your contributions done under LGPLv2 to LGPLv2 or LGPLv3?
+
* Are you okay with relicensing your contributions done under "LGPLv2" to "LGPLv2 or LGPLv3"?
  
 
* Are you okay with the KDE e.V. deciding on a future licensing change to your code, should that be necessary?
 
* Are you okay with the KDE e.V. deciding on a future licensing change to your code, should that be necessary?
  
=== Whats next? ===
+
=== What's next? ===
  
 
# you checkout relicensecheck.pl from trunk/KDE/kdesdk/scripts
 
# you checkout relicensecheck.pl from trunk/KDE/kdesdk/scripts
 
# you run it on the file or directory in question
 
# you run it on the file or directory in question
# you interpret the result. check each commit that is being complained about carefully. Try to get the copyright's holder's permission. if you get it, update the whitelist in the script.
+
# you interpret the result. check each commit that is being complained about carefully. Try to get the copyright's holder's permission. If you get it, update the whitelist in the script.
 
# review the list of declared copyright holders in the file.
 
# review the list of declared copyright holders in the file.
 
# if you're all clear, change the license to the most liberal license possible. Document your change verbosely in the SVN commit log.
 
# if you're all clear, change the license to the most liberal license possible. Document your change verbosely in the SVN commit log.
Line 42: Line 42:
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Adam, Till || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 
|Adam, Till || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 +
|-
 +
|Allen, Danny || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Alsina, Roberto || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Alsina, Roberto || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
Line 48: Line 50:
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Bastian, Waldo || NO || NO || YES || YES || YES
 
|Bastian, Waldo || NO || NO || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Berger, Cyrille || NO || NO || NO || NO || NO
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Boemann, Casper || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Boemann, Casper || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Broadstone, Matt || NO || NO || YES || YES || YES
 
|Broadstone, Matt || NO || NO || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Broeksema, Bertjan || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 +
|-
 +
|Coates, Parker || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Codrea, Vlad || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Connell, Charles || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 
|Connell, Charles || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
Line 64: Line 74:
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Faure, David || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Faure, David || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Fernández, Rafael || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Granroth, Kurt || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Granroth, Kurt || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Harris, Jason || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Haumann, Dominik || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Hausmann, Simon || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Hausmann, Simon || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Hoeglund, Fredrik || NO || NO || YES || YES ||
 
|Hoeglund, Fredrik || NO || NO || YES || YES ||
 +
|-
 +
|Howell, Michael || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Huerlimann, Simon || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Jarvie, David || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Kainhofer, Reinhold || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Kainhofer, Reinhold || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Kellet, Alexander || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Kellet, Alexander || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Kloecker, Ingo || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Knight, Robert || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Knight, Robert || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Koenig, Tobias || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Kretz, Matthias || NO || NO || YES || YES || NO
 
|Kretz, Matthias || NO || NO || YES || YES || NO
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Kulow, Stephan || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 
|Kulow, Stephan || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 +
|-
 +
|Lee, Chris || NO || NO || YES || YES || YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Lunak, Lubos || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 
|Lunak, Lubos || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
Line 103: Line 131:
 
|Mutz, Marc || YES || YES || NO || NO || NO
 
|Mutz, Marc || YES || YES || NO || NO || NO
 
|-
 
|-
 +
|Nyblom, Torgny || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 
|Ottens, Kevin || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Ottens, Kevin || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Peilicke, Sascha || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 +
|-
 +
|Pignet, Eric || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Pipping, Sebastian || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Pyne, Michael || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Pyne, Michael || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Raabe, Frerich || NO || NO || YES || YES || NO
 
|Raabe, Frerich || NO || NO || YES || YES || NO
 +
|-
 +
|Rahn, Torsten  || NO || NO || YES || YES || YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Riddell, Jonathan || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Riddell, Jonathan || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Sand, Espen || YES || YES || || || YES
 
|Sand, Espen || YES || YES || || || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Sanders, Don || YES || YES || YES || YES || No
 +
|-
 +
|Sauer, Sebastian || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Schlaeger, Chris || NO || NO || YES || YES || NO
 
|Schlaeger, Chris || NO || NO || YES || YES || NO
 +
|-
 +
|Schmeisser, Simon || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Schumacher, Cornelius || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Schumacher, Cornelius || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
Line 126: Line 170:
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Toscano, Pino || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Toscano, Pino || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Treat, Adam || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Trueg, Sebastian (Exception: K3b) || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Trueg, Sebastian (Exception: K3b) || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
Line 136: Line 182:
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Wolfer, Urs || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|Wolfer, Urs || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|Yrvin, Knut || YES || YES || YES || YES || YES
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Zachmann, Thorsten || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
 
|Zachmann, Thorsten || YES || YES || YES || YES || NO
Line 144: Line 192:
  
 
* KDAB
 
* KDAB
* Tobias Koenig
+
* Alex Zepeda [mail sent by David Faure]
* Matthew Woehlke
+
* Daniel Teske
+
* Dawit Alemayehu
+
* Alex Zepeda
+
 
* Thomas Leitner
 
* Thomas Leitner
 
* Lars Knoll
 
* Lars Knoll
* Kevin Ottens
 
 
* Maksim Orlovich
 
* Maksim Orlovich
* Sirtaj Singh Kang
 
 
* Karol Szwed
 
* Karol Szwed
* Thorsten Roeder
 
 
* Joseph Wenninger
 
* Joseph Wenninger
 
== Current list of problematic Files ==
 
 
Tom Albers has written a webfrontend to '''relicensecheck.pl''', which makes it really easy to find files that can already be relicensed, or for those that can not it is possible to easily see (via tooltip) which commits are preventing it.
 
 
[http://toma.kovoks.nl/kde/ Visit the Relicensing Status Page]
 
  
 
== Relicensing progress ==
 
== Relicensing progress ==

Revision as of 11:54, 11 September 2012

Contents

KDE GPL v2.0 Relicensing effort

Why does it matter?

A couple of KDE dependent projects or even libraries have moved or are going to move to GPLv3.

Unfortunately, GPL v3 is incompatible with GPL v2. This means that it is not possible to create a project linking GPL v2 and v3 code together. There is no problem for projects which are licensed GPLv2+ (version 2 or above).

A few parts of KDE are currently licensed as GPLv2 only. So far we have no reason to believe that this was something other than an oversight. However, we still need to validate with the individual copyright holders that a relicense to GPLv2+ or GPLv2+v3 is okay with them.

Therefore, in an effort we're trying to identify the contributors that have contributed under the terms of GPLv2 and where the "+" part was not explicitly mentioned. If we know that all contributors agreed to a relicense, we can go ahead and flip the license of the individual source file.

How can I help?

By identifying a contributor who as contributed under the terms of GPLv2 (use kdesdk/scripts/relicensecheck.pl on the file in question), and contacting him if he wasn't already contacted. Ask him the following questions:

  • Are you okay with relicensing your contributions done under "GPLv2" to "GPLv2 or later"?
  • Are you okay with relicensing your contributions done under "GPLv2" to "GPLv2 or GPLv3" ?
  • Are you okay with relicensing your contributions done under "LGPLv2" to "LGPLv2 or later"?
  • Are you okay with relicensing your contributions done under "LGPLv2" to "LGPLv2 or LGPLv3"?
  • Are you okay with the KDE e.V. deciding on a future licensing change to your code, should that be necessary?

What's next?

  1. you checkout relicensecheck.pl from trunk/KDE/kdesdk/scripts
  2. you run it on the file or directory in question
  3. you interpret the result. check each commit that is being complained about carefully. Try to get the copyright's holder's permission. If you get it, update the whitelist in the script.
  4. review the list of declared copyright holders in the file.
  5. if you're all clear, change the license to the most liberal license possible. Document your change verbosely in the SVN commit log.

Current Reply List

  • Please keep the list sorted by family name!
  • Please only use "YES" or "NO"
Name GPLv2->GPLv2+ LGPLv2 -> LGPLv2+ GPLv2 -> GPLv2+v3 LGPLv2 -> LGPLv2+LGPLv3 KDE e.V. decides
Adam, Till YES YES YES YES NO
Allen, Danny YES YES YES YES YES
Alsina, Roberto YES YES YES YES YES
Armitage, Chani YES YES YES YES YES
Bastian, Waldo NO NO YES YES YES
Berger, Cyrille NO NO NO NO NO
Boemann, Casper YES YES YES YES YES
Broadstone, Matt NO NO YES YES YES
Broeksema, Bertjan YES YES YES YES NO
Coates, Parker YES YES YES YES YES
Codrea, Vlad YES YES YES YES NO
Connell, Charles YES YES YES YES NO
Cullmann, Christoph NO NO YES YES NO
Drummond, Craig YES YES YES YES YES
Dymo, Alexander YES YES YES YES NO
Edghill, Gregg YES YES YES YES NO
Faure, David YES YES YES YES YES
Fernández, Rafael YES YES YES YES YES
Granroth, Kurt YES YES YES YES YES
Harris, Jason YES YES YES YES YES
Haumann, Dominik YES YES YES YES NO
Hausmann, Simon YES YES YES YES YES
Hoeglund, Fredrik NO NO YES YES
Howell, Michael YES YES YES YES YES
Huerlimann, Simon YES YES YES YES YES
Jarvie, David YES YES YES YES NO
Kainhofer, Reinhold YES YES YES YES YES
Kellet, Alexander YES YES YES YES YES
Kloecker, Ingo YES YES YES YES NO
Knight, Robert YES YES YES YES YES
Koenig, Tobias YES YES YES YES NO
Kretz, Matthias NO NO YES YES NO
Kulow, Stephan YES YES YES YES NO
Lee, Chris NO NO YES YES YES
Lunak, Lubos YES YES YES YES NO
Mac-Vicar, Duncan YES YES YES YES NO
Macieira, Thiago YES YES YES YES YES
Mantia, Andras NO NO YES YES YES
Martyn, Greg YES YES YES YES YES
McGuire, Thomas YES YES YES YES NO
Molkentin, Daniel YES YES YES YES NO
Montel, Laurent YES YES YES YES YES
Moore, Richard NO NO YES YES YES
Mueller, Dirk YES YES YES YES NO
Mutz, Marc YES YES NO NO NO
Nyblom, Torgny YES YES YES YES YES
Ottens, Kevin YES YES YES YES YES
Peilicke, Sascha YES YES YES YES NO
Pignet, Eric YES YES YES YES YES
Pipping, Sebastian YES YES YES YES NO
Pyne, Michael YES YES YES YES YES
Raabe, Frerich NO NO YES YES NO
Rahn, Torsten NO NO YES YES YES
Riddell, Jonathan YES YES YES YES YES
Sand, Espen YES YES YES
Sanders, Don YES YES YES YES No
Sauer, Sebastian YES YES YES YES NO
Schlaeger, Chris NO NO YES YES NO
Schmeisser, Simon YES YES YES YES YES
Schumacher, Cornelius YES YES YES YES YES
Seigo, Aaron YES YES YES YES YES
Soeken, Mathias YES YES YES YES NO
Stephenson, Will YES YES YES YES YES
Tapsell, John YES YES YES YES YES
Toscano, Pino YES YES YES YES YES
Treat, Adam YES YES YES YES YES
Trueg, Sebastian (Exception: K3b) YES YES YES YES YES
Ventura-Whiting, Ian YES YES YES YES YES
Wallin, Inge YES YES YES YES
Williams, Matt YES YES YES YES YES
Wolfer, Urs YES YES YES YES YES
Yrvin, Knut YES YES YES YES YES
Zachmann, Thorsten YES YES YES YES NO

Current TODO List

  • KDAB
  • Alex Zepeda [mail sent by David Faure]
  • Thomas Leitner
  • Lars Knoll
  • Maksim Orlovich
  • Karol Szwed
  • Joseph Wenninger

Relicensing progress

files_KDE1.png


KDE® and the K Desktop Environment® logo are registered trademarks of KDE e.V.Legal